Blog

/

Serious Crime

Human Trafficking Research: Part 1

Selling water in the desert - how criminal networks exploit the desperate

Posted at

Posted on

Serious Crime

Serious Crime

The business of selling water in the desert

An old and profitable trade

Human trafficking, in the sense of the trade of human beings, is about as old as human society itself. Some of the earliest written evidence comes from ancient Babylon, where the buying, selling and capture of enslaved people were already regulated in the Code of Hammurabi nearly 3,800 years ago.

The largest and most organised manifestation of the trade in human beings was the transatlantic slave trade. Between the 1500s and the 1860s, some 12.5 million Africans were loaded onto European ships and taken to colonies in the Americas. There they were treated as possessions and brutally exploited for the profit, power and territorial reach of European empires.

The laws have since changed, but the logic has not. Then, as now, trafficking is a business of exploitation, built on profit, power and possession.

Profit, power and possession

Anyone can be trafficked, and people of every nationality are. But traffickers do not choose at random. They go where the desperate are, and offer what the desperate want: a job, a way to cross a border or a way to pay off debt.

Vulnerable and manipulated people can be made to do almost anything, so trafficking comes in many forms. Forced labour and sexual exploitation are the two most common, but focusing on them alone obscures a long tail of smaller but no less serious forms of exploitation.

If you focus on human trafficking as organised crime, with a network of people behind each victim, the focus shifts from the victims to the criminals exploiting them. A useful way of sorting it is by the motives of the traffickers. Traffickers are driven by one of three things: profit, power or possession. The motive shapes their methods: whom they recruit, how they coerce and what they demand.

Profit

The motivation for most human trafficking is profit. A trafficker can sell a victim’s labour, body or organs for whatever the market will pay and keep the money themselves. The victim has no say. They are kept under control by having their passports confiscated, their debts inflated so they can never be repaid, or their families threatened.

Trafficking for profit can be caught more easily than other types, as it needs a customer. This buyer-seller relationship, and the paper trail it leaves, can be investigated. Supply chain audits and annual salary reporting help deter forced labour and expose it. Sex trafficking and organ removal both need a buyer and a place to operate. Illegal adoption relies on forged paperwork that can be traced.

Power

Some organisations traffic individuals to build or extend their capacity, recruiting people as tools rather than as goods to be sold.

A gang that needs couriers, or an army that needs soldiers, could recruit individuals by paying them, but coercion is cheaper. People who cannot leave do not need wages, and when they are caught, hurt or killed, they can be replaced.

They also carry the blame. If a teenage courier is arrested, the gang’s leaders are not. Likewise, if a foreign recruit dies in a foreign war, his own government has no say and the state that sent him to war has no one to answer for his death.

Recruitment to organisations can be subtler than coercion. Often these groups provide basic human needs: food, shelter, protection, a sense of belonging and purpose. This draws in people with poor social networks or those in vulnerable positions, offering a route out of deprivation. Once inside, recruits come to rely on the group for these basic human needs, which keeps them loyal and makes leaving unthinkable. With no customer and no sale, this kind of trafficking leaves little trail.

Possession

For some traffickers, controlling the person is the end itself. This category is the hardest to recognise, victims often live with their exploiters and may feel emotional ties to them even while wanting the coercion to end.

Where culture treats marriage or service as a duty, and the victim was raised to agree, neither they nor outsiders may see it as trafficking at all. And because nothing is bought or sold once the victim is inside the home, there is no sale for anyone to trace, which is why these cases last longest.

So, what does it mean to exploit someone?

The UN’s Palermo Protocol says trafficking requires an act, a means and a purpose, the purpose being exploitation. And this covers everything from sexual exploitation to forced armed service to domestic servitude. So then, what does it mean to exploit someone?

A basic understanding of exploitation is to use another person’s vulnerability for one’s own gain. Whether that is wrong depends on what counts as unfair. A boxer who takes advantage of his opponent’s weakness is cheered, and a firm that spots a gap in the market is admired. Advantage-taking is not always a vice.

However, few would defend a deal made between people so unequal that one of them cannot refuse. But what if the weaker party agrees willingly?

Take a hiker lost in the desert, close to collapse, who meets a stranger with a bottle of water. The stranger asks for £1,000 for the water. The hiker pays, drinks and lives. Has the hiker been exploited?

The puzzle is that the sale is mutually advantageous. The seller traded a bottle he valued at almost nothing for £1,000, and the hiker traded £1,000 for her life, so both ended up better off than if no sale had taken place. It is still arguable that the seller has done something wrong: while the hiker is better off than with no deal, she is worse off than she would be under a fair one.

What, then, makes a price fair? A fair price cannot mean equal gain for both participants - the hiker values her life at far more than £1,000, making her the exploiter using this logic. Perhaps a fair price is what the good would fetch in an open competitive market where nobody is under undue pressure; but this fails too as it runs into the problem of what pressure counts as undue.

The hiker’s counterpart is the migrant who agrees to a job abroad, pays a large fee, and arrives to find conditions far worse than promised. She may still be better off than she was at home and worse off than she would have been under a fair deal. Both can be true at once, so has she been exploited?

Perhaps, the better question is why is there someone in the desert selling bottles of water for £1,000?

In an ideal world there would be no hikers who are thirsty and lost in the desert, and there would be no organisation selling water for £1,000. However, it is not an ideal world. Poverty is widespread and people are desperate, a father who cannot feed his children wants to believe a stranger’s promise of work abroad.

Traffickers do not create this desperation. Like the seller in the desert, they find it and exploit it. The place to catch them is where they go looking for it.

Where Kuro fits

Transnational trafficking is organised crime. Recruiting someone, moving them and keeping them under control requires a network of people. Given how many victims there are, convictions are strikingly rare. This is partly because most cases rest on the testimony of traumatised victims, which can be inconsistent and withheld out of fear.

Instead, investigators could start earlier, with how traffickers recruit. Recruitment is the stage where traffickers are most exposed, having to reach out and find their victims. Investigative analysis of recruitment tactics, advertisements, fake jobs and scholarships can reveal the network behind them.

Kuro can help with this.

Kuro lets analysts work inside the online environments where traffickers recruit, from closed forums to messaging groups, without revealing the identity of the investigator.

Analysts can be deployed quickly into any online environment, their identity shielded throughout. The result is intelligence-gathering that is efficient, safe and secure, enabling lawful investigative work to reach beyond traditional online limits.


Kuro supports lawful intelligence and investigative research for government agencies, law enforcement, journalistic and accredited private sector organisations. All use of the platform is subject to Kuro's Acceptable Use Policy and applicable legal frameworks.